Insurance Agency Serving Northern Indiana

Coverage Made Simple Since 1982.

Michaels Insurance Agency helps Northern Indiana drivers and homeowners find affordable coverage for every situation, including SR-22s, non-owner policies, lapses in coverage, tickets and accidents. Our bilingual, Spanish-speaking team makes it simple.

Start a Quote in Minutes

Local, independent and bilingual, right here in downtown Goshen.

Insurance Made Simple

Insurance doesn’t have to be complicated. Since 1982, Michaels Insurance has helped individuals and families find coverage that fits their budget. We make it simple to understand your coverage and get the protection you actually need.

Great driving record or a complicated history? We'll help you find coverage that fits.

Bundle & Save

Affordable Home Insurance

Whether you own your home, rent, or live in a manufactured home, we'll help you find affordable coverage that fits your needs and budget.

  • Homeowners
  • Renters
  • Manufactured Home
  • Bundle & Save Discounts
Start A Quote

Most home quotes take under 5 minutes.

SR-22 Ready

Affordable Auto Insurance

Whether you need standard coverage, an SR-22, or have tickets, accidents, or a lapse in coverage, we'll help you find affordable coverage that fits your needs and budget.

  • Standard & Full Coverage
  • SR-22 Filings
  • Tickets & Accidents
  • Lapse in Coverage
Start A Quote

SR-22 filings handled same day.

Not sure what you need? Talk to a real agent — no pressure, no obligation.

Call (574) 533-4144

Say Goodbye To Frustrating Insurance Experiences

Michaels Insurance Agency storefront at 115 S. Main Street in downtown Goshen, with its red sign above the entrance

Insurance doesn't have to be complicated. With us, it isn't.

Insurance can be overwhelmingly confusing. All of the jargon, terms, and coverages can make you feel like you don't understand any of it. Our team educates our clients so they fully understand what their premium dollars are being spent on.

How To Get Started

We take the hassle out of finding the perfect insurance plan for you. Start a conversation to find out how!

  • Start Online

    Enter some basic information on our website to start.

  • We Shop For You

    We closely review your current policy, checking for coverage levels and exclusions with our multiple carriers.

  • Pick The Best Plan

    Choose the coverage package that fits best.

Start a Quote in Minutes
Quotes Text Call Reviews