Auto Insurance in Indiana

Local Agents. Real Options. Every Driver Welcome.

Michaels Insurance has been helping drivers in Northern Indiana and the surrounding communities since 1982. We’re an independent agency, so we shop multiple carriers to find coverage that fits your budget. Great driving record? We’ll look for competitive rates. Complicated history? We’ll help you find coverage that fits your situation.

Affordable Auto Insurance for Every Situation

Everyone’s insurance needs are different. Whether you’re looking for basic liability coverage, have no prior insurance, have had a lapse in coverage, need an SR-22, or have tickets or accidents on your record, we’ll help you find coverage that fits your needs and budget.

Find Your Situation

Every driver’s story is different. Pick the one that sounds like yours:

• SR-22 Insurance: Need an SR-22 filed with the Indiana BMV? We’ll handle the filing and the policy behind it.
• Never Been Insured / No Prior Insurance: First policy? We’ll help you find carriers that work with new drivers.
• Lapse in Coverage: Let your insurance lapse? We’ll help you get covered again.
• Accidents, DUIs & Tickets: A mistake on your record doesn’t mean you can’t get insured.
• Non-Owner Insurance: Don’t own a car but still drive? Liability coverage may be the answer.

Looking for something else? We also cover motorcycles, RVs & campers and boats.

Why Drivers Choose Michaels Insurance

• Independent: We compare multiple insurance companies for you, not just one.
• Local: We’re right here at 115 S. Main Street in Goshen. Stop in or call.
• Judgment-free: We work with all kinds of driving records.
• No extra cost: We’re paid by the insurance companies, so using us doesn’t cost you more.
• Se habla español.

Know Your Coverage

Car insurance covers a lot more than your car. A few of the coverages we’ll walk you through:

• Liability (Bodily Injury & Property Damage): Pays for injuries and damage you cause to others. Limits that are too low can put your finances at risk, so we’ll help you choose wisely.
• Collision: Covers damage to your car from an accident with another vehicle or object.
• Comprehensive: Covers non-collision damage like theft, hail, a cracked windshield or hitting an animal.
• Uninsured / Underinsured Motorist: Protects you if the other driver has no insurance or not enough.

Not sure what you need? We’ll explain each option in plain English.

Ready to Compare?

Tell us a little about you and your vehicle, and we’ll shop your options. If you live in Northern Indiana and are looking for a car insurance comparison, Michaels Insurance Agency makes the process of finding the best company and price easy.

We do all the heavy lifting for you!